Difference between revisions of "XvT scoring system"

Jump to navigationJump to search
(Transcription of notes from many years ago)
 
(introduction)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
This page details the scoring system used in [[X-Wing vs. TIE Fighter]], including [[Balance of Power]]. Extensive testing via specially designed custom missions went into the generation of this data.
 +
 +
Though essentially complete, some questions remain that later research can solve.
 
<pre>
 
<pre>
All scores on Easy, with default settings
+
-----------------
Orders and AI level don't matter
+
Basic ship scores
 +
-----------------
 +
X-W      300
 +
Y-W      200
 +
A-W      400
 +
Z-95    160
 +
T/F      200
 +
T/I      300
 +
T/B      300
 +
T/A      500
 +
GUN      400
 +
T-W      200  (T/W)
 +
R-41    240
 +
SHU      400
 +
E/S      800
 +
TRN      300
 +
ATR      480
 +
ETR      600
 +
SPC    1200
 +
CRV      800
 +
FRG    2200
 +
ISD    4000
 +
VSD    2500
 +
INT    2800
 +
CRS    3000
 +
STRKC  2000
 +
DREAD  2500
 +
ESC    2000
 +
TUG      100
 +
HLF      300
 +
CUV      120
 +
CORT    1000
 +
MUTR    1000
 +
FRT      600
 +
CARG    800
 +
CNVYR    600
 +
CN/A    400
 +
CN/B    300
 +
CN/C    300
 +
CN/D    300
 +
CN/E    400
 +
CN/F    400
 +
CN/G    400
 +
CN/H    400
 +
CN/I    400
 +
PLT/1  2600
 +
PLT/2  2600
 +
PLT/3  2600
 +
PLT/4  2600
 +
PLT/5  2600
 +
PLT/6  2600
 +
FAC/1  2600
 +
R&D FC  2600
 +
LAS BAT 2600
 +
WLNCHR  2600
 +
Comm Sat 1  250    ComSat
 +
Comm Sat 2  250
 +
Mine 1      20    MineA?
 +
Mine 2      20    MineB?
 +
Mine 3      20    MineC?
 +
Probe      250
 +
Nav Buoy 1  250  NavBuoy
 +
Nav Buoy 2  250
 +
 
 +
--------------------------
 +
Balance of Power additions
 +
--------------------------
 +
B-W      400
 +
M/CRV  1000
 +
M/FRG  2000
 +
SSD    10200
 +
CRL    2500
 +
M/SC    2500
 +
MTRNS  1200
 +
SHPYD  3300
 +
GPLT    400
 +
REPYD  3000
  
T/F: 200
+
Besides the additional ships, BoP and XvT have no difference in scoring system.
T/I: 300
 
T/B: 300
 
T/A: 500
 
SPC: 1200
 
R-41: 240
 
TRN: 300
 
CN/A: 400
 
Z-95: 160
 
E/S: 800
 
SHU: 400
 
GUN: 400
 
CUV: 120
 
CN/B: 300
 
TUG: 100
 
ATR: 480
 
HLF: 300
 
X-W: 300
 
T-W: 200
 
ETR: 600
 
CN/C: 300
 
Y-W: 200
 
CN/D: 300
 
A-W: 400
 
CRV: 800
 
FRT: 600
 
ESC: 2000
 
ISD: 4000
 
DREAD: 2500
 
CNVYR: 600
 
PLT/2: 2600
 
PLT/1: 2600
 
FRG: 2200
 
CRS: 3000
 
INT: 2800
 
CN/E: 400
 
VSD: 2500
 
CARG: 800
 
STRKC: 2000
 
CN/H: 400
 
CN/G: 400
 
CN/I: 400
 
PLT/3: 2600
 
CORT: 1000
 
CN/F: 400
 
FRT: 600
 
MUTR: 1000
 
LAS BAT: 2600
 
FAC/1: 2600
 
R&D FC: 2600
 
WLNCHR: 2600
 
Comm Sat 1: 250
 
Mine 2: 20
 
Mine 1: 20
 
Nav Buoy 2: 250
 
Nav Buoy 1: 250
 
Mine 3: 20
 
Probe: 250
 
Comm Sat 2: 250
 
PLT/6: 2600
 
PLT/5: 2600
 
PLT/4: 2600
 
  
Medium: multiply easy score by 2
+
(Craft order either from XvTED or ingame)
Hard: multiply easy score by 4
 
  
Mission Complete: 10,000, regardless of difficulty
+
------------------------
 +
Additions to ship scores
 +
------------------------
 +
Add the following to the basic ship scores if the ship possesses any of these items.
  
Preserve your ship using hyperspace: 2x ship value, regardless of difficulty
+
75  chaff
 +
50  flare
 +
75  tractor beam
 +
75  jamming beam
 +
125  decoy beam
  
No T/D in BoP
+
Starfighters only: Warhead point values
No B-W in XvT
+
Multiply points by number of warheads in initial load. Disregard any later firing.
 +
5    Missile
 +
7.5  Torpedo
 +
12.5  Adv Missile
 +
10    Adv Torpedo
 +
20    Bomb
 +
15    Rocket
 +
5    Mag pulse
  
430  T/F, with shields, 2x missiles, bombs, chaff, tractor, top ace, attack player
+
Note: Infinite warheads causes problems (it added no extra points in one test)
390  - double missiles
 
430  - shields added
 
355  - tractor
 
355  - chaff
 
350  - bombs
 
200  - tractor, chaff, bombs, 2x
 
  
200  + 2x by self
+
Items that have no effect on score:
240  + bombs/adv. torpedoes
+
  Orders for ships
230  + rockets/torpedoes
+
  AI level of ships
220  + missiles/mag pulse
+
  Modifying shield levels (none, half, extra, etc.)
250  + adv. missiles
+
  Modifying hyperdrive or lasers
280  + 2x + bombs
 
240  + 1/2x + bombs
 
210  + 1/2x + missiles
 
          so, only if 1/2 is possible.
 
  
275  + chaff
+
-------------------
250  + flare
+
Difficulty modifier
275  + tractor, jamming
+
-------------------
325  + decoy
+
After all of the above have been calculated, then apply difficulty modifier:
  
375 T/I with chaff
+
Easy    no multiplication needed
425  T/I with decoy
+
Medium multiply score by 2
 +
Hard    multiply score by 4
  
200  + no shields (apparently 50% shields), 50% shields, no lasers (did nothing),
 
          no hyperdrive, shields 0% charging (nothing), shields added, hyperdrive added,
 
          infinite missiles
 
  
330  T/I w/missiles
+
------------------
380  T/I w/2x + bombs
+
Additional scoring
340  T/I w/bombs
+
------------------
 +
These items remain the same regardless of difficulty. Do not apply the difficulty modifier.
  
Dying:  - your ship's value.
+
10,000  Mission Complete
  
T/F: 4 missiles, torpedoes, adv. both, mag pulse
+
Preserving your ship using hyperspace: + 2x ship value for each ship, including additions
        2 bombs, rockets
 
  
Missile: 5 [10]
+
Dying: subtract your ship's value, including additions
Torpedo: 7.5 [15]
 
Adv Missile: 12.5 [25]
 
Adv Torpedo: 10 [20]
 
Bomb: 20 [40]
 
Rocket: 15 [30]
 
Mag pulse: 5 [10]
 
  
XvT
+
Your personal warhead launching:
X-W
+
Missile fired:  -10  Hit: +10
Y-W
+
Bomb:          -40  Hit: +40
A-W
 
Z-95
 
T/F
 
T/I
 
T/B
 
T/A
 
GUN
 
T/W
 
R-41
 
SHU
 
E/S
 
TRN
 
ATR
 
ETR
 
SPC
 
CRV
 
FRG
 
ISD
 
VSD
 
INT
 
CRS
 
STRKC
 
DREAD
 
ESC
 
TUG
 
HLF
 
CUV
 
CORT
 
MUTR
 
FRT
 
CARG
 
CNVYR
 
CN/A
 
CN/B
 
CN/C
 
CN/D
 
CN/E
 
CN/F
 
CN/G
 
CN/H
 
CN/I
 
PLT/1
 
PLT/2
 
PLT/3
 
PLT/4
 
PLT/5
 
PLT/6
 
FAC/1
 
R&D FC
 
LAS BAT
 
WLNCHR
 
ComSat
 
MineA
 
MineB
 
MineC
 
Probe
 
NavBuoy
 
  
BoP:
 
B-W
 
M/CRV
 
M/FRG
 
SSD
 
CRL
 
M/SC
 
MTRNS
 
SHPYD
 
GPLT
 
REPYD
 
  
  
CRV: 0% shields
+
---------------------------
 +
Kill percentage calculation
 +
---------------------------
 +
Your percentage of damage dealt results in your level of kill. You can achieve three levels of kill:
  
Hull
+
1(0)   full kill      66%-100% damage      no multiplication needed
0-69  1(0) 800
+
0(1)   half kill      33%- 66% damage      multiply kill score by 0.5 (50%)
8-88  1(0) 800
+
  1     assist        1%- 33% damage      multiply kill score by 0.1 (10%)
0-55  0(1) 400
 
0-8 1 Assist  80
 
0-22  1 Assist  80
 
0-35  0(1) 400
 
  
CRV: normal
+
The game considers the full range of damage for this calculation, including shields.
 +
For ships without shields, you can easily calculate according to the above percentages.
 +
If ships have shields, the game calculates your percentage of the total damage done,
 +
  even if the ship regenerates some shields.
  
Shields  Hull
+
As an example, say you find a Corvette that has 58% shields and 100% hull left.
0-1    0-100   1 Assist  80
+
   If you alone destroy it, without its shields recharging, you will receive 1(0) kill.
0-48   0-100  0(1)   400
+
However, if you found the same Corvette at 48% shields and 100% hull
0-58  0-100   1(0)  800
+
   and you alone destroy it, without its shields recharging, you will receive 0(1) kill.
0-8   0-100    0(1)   400
 
0-98  87-100  1(0)  800
 
  
33%, 66% as boundaries?
 
1/10, 1/2 as scores
 
Kill shots do not matter
 
  
 +
-------------
 +
Laser studies
 +
-------------
 +
The below information does not concern scoring, but rather the rate at which one destroys a ship.
 +
The faster a ship travels, the more damage its lasers do to another ship.
  
TRN normal: 300
+
Below you may see some example damage research. Using studies of attacks on a CRV,
w/o shields: 300
+
  we can accurately estimate the number of lasers needed to destroy other ships at various speeds
 +
  if we know how many lasers it takes to destroy them at 0 MGLT (while stopped).
  
CRV normal: 800
+
With that information, we can then calculate how long it takes to destroy a ship.
w/o shields: 800
 
  
Missile fired: -10  Hit: +10
+
CRV attack data collected from attack runs that held steady at 0, 60, 105, and 120 MGLT.
Bomb:  -40  Hit: +40
 
  
BoP
+
                0 MGLT  60  105  120
T/F: 200 (still)
+
vs.            Lasers needed for each:  
CRV: 800 (still)
+
CRV   Shields    80    64    55    53
M/SC: 2500
+
        Hull      40    32    28    26
CRL: 2500
+
      Total    120    96    83    79
M/FRG: 2000
 
SHPYD: 3300
 
GPLT: 400
 
B-W: 400
 
M/CRV: 1000
 
REPYD: 3000
 
MTRNS: 1200
 
SSD: 10200
 
  
 +
w = lasers needed at 0 MGLT
 +
y = speed in question (e.g. 105 MGLT)
 +
z = lasers needed at speed in question (e.g. at 105 MGLT)
  
Laser studies
+
wx = yz
  
A-Wing, 0 MGLT      105    60   120
+
MGLT    0   60  105   120
 +
  x    0    48   72   80
 +
ratio  0  0.8  0.69  0.67
  
Ship    Lasers    Time    Las. Las.  Las.
+
Below, we have 0 MGLT data from an attack against a DREAD.
CRV      80        :20    55    64    53
+
60, 105, 120 MGLT data extrapolated according to the formula.
            40        :10    28    32    26
 
  
80 (x / 105) = 55
+
z = wx / y    (faster but less accurate: z = w * ratio)
x = 72
 
  
for 60, x = 48     for 120, x = 80
+
vs.            0 MGLT  60   105  120
 +
DREAD  Shields    528  423  363  352   
 +
        Hull     238  191  164  159
 +
        Total    766  613  526  511
  
MGLT    ratio
 
60    0.8
 
105    0.68
 
120    0.66
 
  
 +
------------
 +
Firing rates
 +
------------
 +
A-Wing:
 +
80 lasers in 20 seconds  (40 duals in 20 seconds)
 
A-Wing firing rate: 2 duals per second
 
A-Wing firing rate: 2 duals per second
  
(0 MGLT)
+
Time needed for an A-Wing to destroy a DREAD which starts at full strength:
DREAD    528    1:55
+
vs.              0 MGLT   60    105  120
              238     0:55
+
DREAD Shields    2:12  1:46  1:31  1:28   
              766
+
        Hull     1:00  0:48  0:41  0:40
 +
        Total    3:12  2:34  2:12  2:08
 +
 
 +
Obviously, however, a ship at, say, 120 MGLT cannot sustain an attack for two minutes without
 +
  slowing down or spending time pointing away from its target.
 +
These tables serve as only a part of the overall picture of attack runs.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
Another ship not recorded (X-Wing, perhaps?):
 +
528 lasers in 115 seconds
 +
238 lasers in 55 seconds
 +
766 lasers in 170 seconds (383 duals in 170 seconds)
 +
Firing rate: 2.253 duals per second
 +
 
 +
 
 +
 
 +
--------
 +
Research
 +
--------
 +
You may ignore the below.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
Kill percentage research
 +
----
 +
CRV: 0% shields
 +
 
 +
Hull
 +
0-69    1(0)    800
 +
8-88   1(0)    800  (i.e. another ship fired the final shots)
 +
0-55    0(1)    400
 +
0- 8  1 Assist  80
 +
0-22  1 Assist  80
 +
0-35    0(1)    400
 +
 
 +
CRV: normal
 +
 
 +
Shields    Hull
 +
  0- 1    0-100  1 Assist  80
 +
  0-48    0-100    0(1)    400
 +
  0-58    0-100    1(0)    800
 +
  0- 8    0-100    0(1)    400
 +
  0-98  87-100     1(0)    800
 +
 
 +
------
 +
 
 +
 
 +
T/F can carry: 4 missiles, torpedoes, adv missiles, adv torpedoes, mag pulse
 +
        2 bombs, rockets
 +
 
  
766 (.7) = 536 : 268 dual shots
+
----
(100 MGLT)
 
134 seconds
 
 
</pre>
 
</pre>

Latest revision as of 18:52, 13 January 2014

This page details the scoring system used in X-Wing vs. TIE Fighter, including Balance of Power. Extensive testing via specially designed custom missions went into the generation of this data.

Though essentially complete, some questions remain that later research can solve.

-----------------
Basic ship scores
-----------------
X-W      300
Y-W      200
A-W      400
Z-95     160
T/F      200
T/I      300
T/B      300
T/A      500
GUN      400
T-W      200   (T/W)
R-41     240
SHU      400
E/S      800
TRN      300
ATR      480
ETR      600
SPC     1200
CRV      800
FRG     2200
ISD     4000
VSD     2500
INT     2800
CRS     3000
STRKC   2000
DREAD   2500
ESC     2000
TUG      100
HLF      300
CUV      120
CORT    1000
MUTR    1000
FRT      600
CARG     800
CNVYR    600
CN/A     400
CN/B     300
CN/C     300
CN/D     300
CN/E     400
CN/F     400
CN/G     400
CN/H     400
CN/I     400
PLT/1   2600
PLT/2   2600
PLT/3   2600
PLT/4   2600
PLT/5   2600
PLT/6   2600
FAC/1   2600
R&D FC  2600
LAS BAT 2600
WLNCHR  2600
Comm Sat 1  250    ComSat
Comm Sat 2  250
Mine 1       20    MineA?
Mine 2       20    MineB?
Mine 3       20    MineC?
Probe       250
Nav Buoy 1  250   NavBuoy
Nav Buoy 2  250

--------------------------
Balance of Power additions
--------------------------
B-W      400
M/CRV   1000
M/FRG   2000
SSD    10200
CRL     2500
M/SC    2500
MTRNS   1200
SHPYD   3300
GPLT     400
REPYD   3000

Besides the additional ships, BoP and XvT have no difference in scoring system.

(Craft order either from XvTED or ingame)

------------------------
Additions to ship scores
------------------------
Add the following to the basic ship scores if the ship possesses any of these items.

 75  chaff
 50  flare
 75  tractor beam
 75  jamming beam
125  decoy beam

Starfighters only: Warhead point values
Multiply points by number of warheads in initial load. Disregard any later firing.
 5    Missile
 7.5  Torpedo
12.5  Adv Missile
10    Adv Torpedo
20    Bomb
15    Rocket
 5    Mag pulse

Note: Infinite warheads causes problems (it added no extra points in one test)

Items that have no effect on score:
  Orders for ships
  AI level of ships
  Modifying shield levels (none, half, extra, etc.)
  Modifying hyperdrive or lasers

-------------------
Difficulty modifier
-------------------
After all of the above have been calculated, then apply difficulty modifier:

Easy    no multiplication needed
Medium  multiply score by 2
Hard    multiply score by 4


------------------
Additional scoring
------------------
These items remain the same regardless of difficulty. Do not apply the difficulty modifier.

10,000   Mission Complete

Preserving your ship using hyperspace: + 2x ship value for each ship, including additions

Dying: subtract your ship's value, including additions

Your personal warhead launching:
Missile fired:  -10   Hit: +10
Bomb:           -40   Hit: +40



---------------------------
Kill percentage calculation
---------------------------
Your percentage of damage dealt results in your level of kill. You can achieve three levels of kill:

1(0)   full kill      66%-100% damage       no multiplication needed
0(1)   half kill      33%- 66% damage       multiply kill score by 0.5 (50%)
 1      assist         1%- 33% damage       multiply kill score by 0.1 (10%)

The game considers the full range of damage for this calculation, including shields.
For ships without shields, you can easily calculate according to the above percentages.
If ships have shields, the game calculates your percentage of the total damage done,
   even if the ship regenerates some shields.

As an example, say you find a Corvette that has 58% shields and 100% hull left.
  If you alone destroy it, without its shields recharging, you will receive 1(0) kill.
However, if you found the same Corvette at 48% shields and 100% hull
  and you alone destroy it, without its shields recharging, you will receive 0(1) kill.


-------------
Laser studies
-------------
The below information does not concern scoring, but rather the rate at which one destroys a ship.
The faster a ship travels, the more damage its lasers do to another ship.

Below you may see some example damage research. Using studies of attacks on a CRV,
  we can accurately estimate the number of lasers needed to destroy other ships at various speeds
  if we know how many lasers it takes to destroy them at 0 MGLT (while stopped).

With that information, we can then calculate how long it takes to destroy a ship.

CRV attack data collected from attack runs that held steady at 0, 60, 105, and 120 MGLT.

                0 MGLT   60   105   120
vs.             Lasers needed for each: 
CRV   Shields     80     64    55    53
        Hull      40     32    28    26
       Total     120     96    83    79

w = lasers needed at 0 MGLT
y = speed in question (e.g. 105 MGLT)
z = lasers needed at speed in question (e.g. at 105 MGLT)

wx = yz

MGLT    0    60   105   120
  x     0    48    72    80
ratio   0   0.8  0.69  0.67

Below, we have 0 MGLT data from an attack against a DREAD.
60, 105, 120 MGLT data extrapolated according to the formula.

z = wx / y    (faster but less accurate: z = w * ratio)

vs.             0 MGLT   60   105   120
DREAD  Shields    528   423   363   352    
         Hull     238   191   164   159
        Total     766   613   526   511


------------
Firing rates
------------
A-Wing:
80 lasers in 20 seconds   (40 duals in 20 seconds)
A-Wing firing rate: 2 duals per second

Time needed for an A-Wing to destroy a DREAD which starts at full strength:
vs.              0 MGLT   60    105   120
DREAD  Shields    2:12   1:46  1:31  1:28    
         Hull     1:00   0:48  0:41  0:40
        Total     3:12   2:34  2:12  2:08

Obviously, however, a ship at, say, 120 MGLT cannot sustain an attack for two minutes without
  slowing down or spending time pointing away from its target.
These tables serve as only a part of the overall picture of attack runs.


Another ship not recorded (X-Wing, perhaps?):
528 lasers in 115 seconds
238 lasers in 55 seconds
766 lasers in 170 seconds (383 duals in 170 seconds)
Firing rate: 2.253 duals per second



--------
Research
--------
You may ignore the below.


Kill percentage research
----
CRV: 0% shields

Hull
0-69    1(0)    800
8-88    1(0)    800   (i.e. another ship fired the final shots)
0-55    0(1)    400
0- 8  1 Assist   80
0-22  1 Assist   80
0-35    0(1)    400

CRV: normal

Shields    Hull
  0- 1    0-100   1 Assist   80
  0-48    0-100     0(1)    400
  0-58    0-100     1(0)    800
  0- 8    0-100     0(1)    400
  0-98   87-100     1(0)    800

------


T/F can carry:  4 missiles, torpedoes, adv missiles, adv torpedoes, mag pulse
        2 bombs, rockets


----